Earth Pressure TBM Dual-mode Shield and Slurry TBM Dual-mode Shield

2026-11-18

Abstract:In long-distance tunnel construction, composite strata with alternating soft soil, fractured surrounding rock and hard rock impose stringent requirements on tunnelling equipment. A single-type shield or TBM often fails to satisfy the requirements of construction safety, ground settlement control and tunnelling efficiency simultaneously. As mainstream composite tunnelling machines, earth pressure TBM dual-mode shields and slurry TBM dual-mode shields are capable of switching between soft-soil balanced tunnelling mode and hard-rock TBM tunnelling mode, making them suitable for tunnel projects with variable geological conditions. This paper introduces the application scope and working principle of the two types of dual-mode shields respectively, and conducts a comparative analysis from dimensions including face stabilization mechanism, mucking method, supporting facilities, construction cost and risk characteristics. It clarifies the selection boundary of the two machines and provides technical references for equipment selection in metro tunnels, water diversion tunnels, river-crossing and sea-crossing tunnels and other projects.

【This article is compiled for popular science purposes in the industry. Part of the technical data refers to publicly available professional literature.】

In long-distance tunnel projects, composite strata with alternating soft soil, fractured surrounding rock and intact hard rock are frequently encountered. Single-mode shields or hard-rock TBMs cannot balance face stability, tunnelling efficiency and construction safety. An earth pressure/TBM dual-mode shield or slurry/TBM dual-mode shield integrates a soft-soil balanced shield and a hard-rock TBM on one main machine, and can switch between two modes according to geological variations. Representing high-end mainstream equipment for tunnel construction across alternating soft and hard strata, they are widely applied in rail transit, water diversion tunnels, river-crossing and sea-crossing tunnels and other projects.

Ⅰ Earth Pressure TBM Dual-mode Shield (EPB‑TBM Dual-mode)

An earth pressure TBM dual-mode shield, also known as EPB/TBM dual-mode shield, refers to the dual-mode tunnelling equipment combining earth pressure balance and hard-rock TBM functions. Equipped with both an earth pressure balance system and a TBM hard-rock tunnelling structure on the main machine, it can switch between earth pressure balance mode and single-shield TBM mode, suitable for tunnels constructed in composite strata with alternating soft soil, upper-soft-and-lower-hard formations, fractured rock and medium-hard rock.

1.Scope of Application

The earth pressure TBM dual-mode shield is preferable for strata with **moderate water pressure and low-to-medium permeability**. Typical scenarios are listed below:

(1)Soft clay, silt, silty clay, residual soil, weathered rock and upper-soft-and-lower-hard strata with low groundwater pressure and low risk of water surge;

(2)Soft soil sections requiring strict ground settlement control, while hard rock sections mainly consist of moderately and slightly weathered rock with uniaxial compressive strength generally ranging from 30 MPa to 120 MPa;

(3)Urban metro tunnels and mountain water diversion tunnels where surface structures are dense, settlement control is required, and there is no available large site for slurry treatment;

(4)Frequently alternating strata: intermittent soft soil/fracture zones and intact hard rock. The hard rock section features favourable self-stability and no highly permeable sandy gravel layers.

Limitations: In strata with high water pressure, highly permeable coarse sand or large-diameter gravel, the earth pressure mode is prone to water surge and face instability, restricting its adaptability.

2.Working Principle

(1)Earth Pressure Balance Mode (EPB Mode): The cutterhead excavates soil, and the excavated muck fills the earth chamber. The plastic flow property of conditioned muck generates earth pressure to balance the water and earth pressure on the tunnel face. Muck is discharged via a screw conveyor. The rotating speed of the screw conveyor and advance rate are synchronously controlled to stabilize the earth chamber pressure and limit ground settlement. Foam and bentonite systems are adopted to condition muck and prevent mud cake and water surge.

(2)TBM Hard-rock Mode: The screw conveyor and related EPB auxiliary components are removed or isolated, and the mucking system is switched to a belt conveyor. Disc cutters on the cutterhead break rock. The surrounding rock stabilizes by itself or is supported by the single shield. TBM tunnelling parameters (high rotating speed and low torque) are adopted for rapid excavation. The excavation chamber no longer relies on muck pressure to stabilize the face; stability is mainly provided by the self-supporting capacity of intact hard rock, which greatly improves tunnelling efficiency in hard rock sections.

When switching between the two modes, modification and sealing of the earth chamber, mucking passage and pipelines are required. The switching procedure is relatively manageable with low requirements on site supporting facilities.

Ⅱ Slurry TBM Dual-mode Shield (Slurry‑TBM Dual-mode)

A slurry TBM dual-mode shield is a dual-mode tunnelling equipment integrating slurry balance and hard-rock TBM functions. It incorporates a slurry circulation system and hard-rock TBM structure on one machine and supports switching between slurry balance mode and hard-rock TBM tunnelling mode. It is designed primarily for working conditions featuring high water pressure, highly permeable composite strata and long-distance hard rock.

1. Scope of Application

The advantages of the slurry TBM dual-mode shield are prominent in water-rich and highly permeable strata:

(1)Water-rich fine sand, medium-coarse sand, sandy gravel and highly weathered fracture zones with high groundwater pressure and high permeability, where the earth pressure mode cannot reliably stabilize the tunnel face;

(2)River-crossing, sea-crossing and deep-buried tunnels with extremely strict requirements on face water inrush prevention and ground settlement control;

(3)Long-distance composite strata with water-permeable soft soil under high water pressure in the front section and continuous intact hard rock in the rear section; the uniaxial compressive strength of hard rock can reach 150 MPa or higher;

(4) Projects with available space at the tunnel portal for slurry separation plants and conditions for slurry treatment and disposal under environmental regulations.

Limitations: The slurry system occupies a large area, consumes high energy and incurs high slurry treatment costs. Mud cake easily forms on the cutterhead and pipelines in clayey strata, increasing cleaning workload. It is not recommended for narrow urban sites with strict environmental restrictions and no slurry disposal conditions.

2. Working Principle

(1)Slurry Balance Mode: Bentonite slurry is pumped into the excavation chamber to form a filter cake on the tunnel face. The hydrostatic pressure of slurry balances the earth and water pressure. Excavated rock-soil fragments mix with slurry and are transported through slurry pipelines to a slurry separation plant outside the tunnel. After solid-liquid separation, the slurry is recycled. The pressure on the tunnel face is regulated through coordinated control of feed/discharge slurry flow rate, liquid level and air cushion chamber pressure. This mode delivers high pressure control precision and strong resistance against sand and water inrush.


(2)TBM Hard-rock Mode: The slurry circulation system is shut down, slurry pipelines are sealed off, and the mucking system is switched to the TBM belt conveyor system. Disc cutters break the rock, and rock chips are conveyed by belt conveyors. Tunnelling proceeds depending on the self-stability of hard surrounding rock or shield support, without slurry for face stabilization. This gives full play to the rapid excavation advantage of TBM in intact hard rock.

Switching from slurry mode to TBM mode requires isolation and sealing of circulation pipelines and the air cushion chamber, which is more complicated than mode conversion of the earth pressure TBM dual-mode shield.

Ⅲ Comparison between Earth Pressure TBM Dual-mode Shield and Slurry TBM Dual-mode Shield

Comparison Item

Earth Pressure TBM Dual-mode (EPB‑TBM)

Slurry TBM Dual-mode (Slurry‑TBM)

Core AdvantagesSimple structure, fewer auxiliary systems, low energy consumption and lower capital cost; muck is directly transported out without slurry plants; less prone to mud cake in clayey strata, suitable for urban metro projectsStrong face stability in high-water-pressure and highly permeable sandy gravel strata; higher settlement control precision, suitable for deep river/sea-crossing tunnels; higher upper limit of rock strength
Face Stabilizing MediumConditioned muck generating earth pressureSlurry plus filter cake providing fluid pressure
Mucking MethodEPB: screw conveyor; TBM: belt conveyorSlurry mode: slurry pipeline pumping; TBM: belt conveyor
Preferred StrataLow water pressure, clay, weathered rock, upper-soft-and-lower-hard formations, moderately permeable strataHigh water pressure, water-rich sand, gravel, fracture zones plus long-distance hard rock
Site RequirementsOnly muck stacking and haulage, small footprintLarge supporting facilities for slurry separation, sedimentation and filter pressing, large footprint
Energy Consumption & Operation CostLow, few consumables, favourable overall construction costHigh, high consumption of bentonite, additives and pump power; expensive slurry disposal
Main RisksProne to water surge in high-water-pressure highly permeable layers; difficult muck conditioning in fine sand strataMud cake on cutterhead and pipeline blockage in clayey and silty clay strata; slurry leakage and stringent environmental control pressure
Typical Engineering ScenariosUrban metro tunnels, shallow mountain water diversion tunnels, composite strata with limited groundwaterRiver-crossing tunnels, sea-crossing tunnels, deep-buried high-water-pressure water conveyance tunnels, water-rich sandy gravel composite strata
Mode Switching DifficultyModerate, mainly modification of screw conveyor passageRelatively high, complicated isolation and sealing of slurry pipelines and air cushion chamber

Conclusion

Neither the earth pressure TBM dual-mode shield nor the slurry TBM dual-mode shield is universally superior. The core selection criteria are stratum condition and water pressure. The earth pressure TBM dual-mode shield is preferred for projects with low groundwater pressure, clay and weathered rock as dominant strata and limited urban construction space. The slurry TBM dual-mode shield is a more reliable option for projects involving high water pressure, thick sandy gravel layers, river or sea crossing and other scenarios with prominent water inrush risks. The technical value of dual-mode TBMs lies in solving two core challenges with one machine: preventing collapse in soft soil and achieving rapid excavation in hard rock. It greatly reduces downtime caused by cutter replacement or equipment changeover and serves as core machinery for mechanized tunnelling in long tunnels with complex geology.

 

 

References:

DU Yanliang. Training Course for Shield Machine Practitioners[M]. Fuzhou: Fujian Science and Technology Press, 2022.

Note: This article is only for industry technical popular science. Part of technical principles refer to the above‑mentioned publicly‑available professional book. All viewpoints herein are for industry exchange only.

Previous:

NEWS

Earth Pressure TBM Dual-mode Shield and Slurry TBM Dual-mode Shield

Abstract:In long-distance tunnel construction, composite strata with alternating soft soil, fractured surrounding rock and hard rock impose stringent requirements on tunnelling equipment. A single-type shield or TBM often fails to satisfy the requirements of construction safety, ground settlement control and tunnelling efficiency simultaneously. As mainstream composite tunnelling machines, earth pressure TBM dual-mode shields and slurry TBM dual-mode shields are capable of switching between soft-soil balanced tunnelling mode and hard-rock TBM tunnelling mode, making them suitable for tunnel projects with variable geological conditions. This paper introduces the application scope and working principle of the two types of dual-mode shields respectively, and conducts a comparative analysis from dimensions including face stabilization mechanism, mucking method, supporting facilities, construction cost and risk characteristics. It clarifies the selection boundary of the two machines and provides technical references for equipment selection in metro tunnels, water diversion tunnels, river-crossing and sea-crossing tunnels and other projects.

Earth Pressure Balance‑Slurry Dual‑Mode Shield Machine

Abstract: This paper focuses on the earth pressure balance (EPB)‑slurry dual‑mode shield machine, defines its applicable strata and typical engineering scenarios, and elaborates respectively on the working principles and pressure control logic under EPB and slurry tunnelling modes. According to the pressure regulation mechanism of the excavation chamber, the equipment is classified into the direct‑controlled single‑cabin type and the indirect‑controlled air‑cushion double‑cabin type, whose advantages and disadvantages are compared. Finally, from four dimensions including cabin structure, crusher layout, pipeline configuration and grouting logic of the air‑cushion chamber, this paper clarifies the core design differences between the indirect‑controlled dual‑mode shield and the conventional indirect‑controlled air‑cushion slurry shield. The research can provide a technical basis for type selection, structural design and mode‑switching construction of dual‑mode shields for composite‑stratum tunnels. 【This article is compiled for popular science purposes in the industry. Part of the technical data refers to publicly available professional literature.】